Woman in Aerie boyshort underwear.

We all know the feeling of reaching into our underwear drawer and finding that perfect pair – soft, comfy and just right for the day ahead. But as time goes on (and life happens), your fav undies can start to lose their magic. Whether it’s from wear and tear, the natural fading of fabric, or just a shift in style, knowing when to replace your underwear is key to feeling your best, every day. Here are 5 signs that your top drawer is definitely due for a refresh:

1. The Elastic is Losing Its Stretch

The elastic waistband is what keeps your undies in place, but over time, it can start to lose its stretch. If you notice your favorite pair of underwear slipping down or feeling a little loose around the waist, it’s a sign that the elastic is no longer doing its job. While comfort is key, a pair that constantly slides down can become annoying and distracting. Check the waistband for any signs of stretched-out elastic or loose threads. If it’s not holding its shape, it’s time to look for a new pair with a high-quality, comfy elastic waistband!

Aerie black thong underwear.

2. The Fabric Feels Rough or Worn Out

We’ve all been there: a pair of undies that once felt so soft, but now feels like sandpaper against your skin. When the fabric starts to lose its softness, it’s a sign that your undies have been through one too many washes. This is especially true if you’ve noticed pilling (those little fabric balls) or thinning spots in the material. If your undies are starting to feel uncomfortable or rough, it’s time to replace them with a new, fresh pair that make you feel comfortable and confident.

Woman in Aerie underwear.

3. There Are Holes or Rips

Life happens – whether it’s a snag from jewelry or just regular wear and tear, holes or rips can sneak up on your undies. Small holes may seem like no big deal, but they can quickly grow larger and lead to uncomfortable situations. Plus, once they’ve been damaged, they’re unlikely to stay in shape for long. If you notice any holes or tears, it’s time to treat yourself to new underwear.

4. They’ve Lost Their Shape

We all know the feeling of putting on your undies and realizing they’re not sitting quite right anymore. Whether they’re sagging, bunching, or just not hugging your body the way they used to, a loss of shape is a clear sign that it’s time for a replacement. Undies should move with you, not against you, and if they’ve lost their fit, it’s time for an upgrade.

Woman in Aerie thong.

5. They Don’t Match Your Current Style

Sometimes, it’s not about wear and tear, but about your personal style evolving. If your undies are no longer reflecting who you are or don’t match your vibe anymore, it might be time for a refresh. Maybe you’ve swapped out a few pairs for a more comfy, laid-back style or want to add a little more flirt to your collection. Your underwear should make you feel like your best self and when they no longer fit that vibe, it’s time for an update.

Treat Yourself to New Underwear

Think of it this way, replacing your undies when they’ve reached the end of their life cycle is key to keeping your comfort and confidence high. Whether it’s the elastic, the fabric, or the style, you deserve underwear that makes you feel amazing every day. 

At Aerie, we’ve got you covered with a variety of styles and fits that keep you feeling comfortable, confident, and ready to take on anything. So, look through your drawer and see what’s ready to be retired – your fresh, new favs are waiting for you at Aerie.

See more

A woman in a matching lavender set from Aerie.
Style & Trends

Soft Aesthetic: Cozy & Completely You

If your dream day includes self-care, oversized cozy knits, soothing pastel hues and romanticizing the…

Woman in Aerie long sleeve top and maxi skirt.
Style & Trends

Spring 2026 Trends: Fresh Looks to Try This Season

Spring is here and so are the vibes! This season is all about going BIG…

Woman in Aerie bralette and sweatpants.
Style & Trends

Bras vs. Bralettes: The Ultimate Showdown

When it comes to choosing the perfect intimates, it’s easy to feel overwhelmed by the…

Share your comments

Thanks for sharing! Your comment will post soon. We double check first to make sure #AerieREAL Life is always a safe, positive space.